The Senior Benefits Center
← All articles How to Review Medicare Plans 2026: A Step-by-Step Guide How-to

How to Review Medicare Plans 2026: A Step-by-Step Guide

Table of Contents

Last Updated: September 4, 2026

Many beneficiaries let their Medicare coverage auto-renew without reviewing it, but plans change their premiums, deductibles, provider networks, and drug formularies annually, and so do your health needs. This guide from The Senior Benefits Center breaks down a practical, step-by-step process to evaluate your options before the enrollment deadline, protecting both your health and your budget.

Why Review Your Medicare Plans Annually

The Annual Notice of Change document that arrives each fall is your most important trigger for review. Beneficiaries who skip this step often discover in January that their plan no longer covers a critical medication or that their preferred doctor has left the network, expensive surprises that an annual review prevents.

Your healthcare needs rarely stay static. A new diagnosis, a change in prescriptions, or a planned surgery can all alter which plan structure suits you best. Many beneficiaries find that reviewing their plan benefits each year takes less than an hour when they know exactly what to look for, yet it can save hundreds of dollars in out-of-pocket costs over the next twelve months. The official Medicare.gov guidance on plan changes provides a clear baseline for what you should verify each cycle.

Understanding Medicare Star Ratings 2026

Medicare's star ratings are the government's quality scorecard for health and drug plans, measuring member satisfaction and chronic disease management. The 2026 ratings reflect two years of plan performance. Five-star plans demonstrate high quality; lower-rated plans may be adequate but warrant closer scrutiny.

Star ratings matter because they translate directly into the beneficiary experience. Plans earning four or more stars often have better-managed care coordination, fewer complaints, and more responsive customer service. When you compare two plans with similar costs and coverage, the star rating is an excellent tiebreaker, and the CMS star ratings methodology explains exactly how these scores are calculated. The Senior Benefits Center recommends filtering your comparison to plans with at least a 3.5-star rating unless you have a specific reason to consider otherwise.

Pro Tip You can switch to a five-star Medicare Advantage plan outside the standard enrollment periods using the Medicare Advantage Five-Star Special Enrollment Period, available once per year between December 8 and November 30.

Step 1: Gather Your Current Plan Documents

Collect your current plan's Summary of Benefits, Annual Notice of Change, prescription drug formulary, and a list of anticipated medical services for 2026. Organizing these documents first prevents comparing plans without knowing your baseline.

The Annual Notice of Change itemizes shifts in your current plan: premiums, deductibles, copayments, provider network, drug tiers, and formulary removals. This gives you a concrete starting point for your review.

Step 2: Use a Medicare Plan Comparison Tool

The Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov is the most comprehensive comparison tool. Enter your ZIP code, current medications, and preferred pharmacies to see personalized cost estimates. Entering specific prescriptions is critical because the same drug costs dramatically different amounts under different Part D plans.

A common mistake is comparing premiums alone. Lower-premium plans often have higher deductibles or less favorable copayments, costing more overall if you use frequent services. The Plan Finder calculates estimated annual costs based on your medications for accurate comparison.

Older adult sitting at a wooden desk with a laptop open to a Medicare plan comparison website, reading glasses in hand, a notepad and pen beside the keyboard, soft afternoon light through a nearby window
Older adult sitting at a wooden desk with a laptop open to a Medicare plan comparison website, reading glasses in hand, a notepad and pen beside the keyboard, soft afternoon light through a nearby window
Key Takeaway Always run a full cost estimate with your specific medications in the Plan Finder. Premiums alone do not tell you which plan is cheapest for your situation.

Step 3: Check for Medicare Part D Formulary Changes

Prescription drug formularies change constantly as carriers renegotiate prices. Medications can move to higher tiers, require prior authorization, or disappear entirely. Check the 2026 formulary for each plan to confirm your prescriptions remain covered at an affordable cost.

Understanding Medicare Part D Formulary Tiers

Medicare Part D plans organize drugs into tiers. Tier 1 (preferred generic) costs $5-$15; Tier 2 (non-preferred generic) $10-$25; Tier 3 (preferred brand) $30-$50; Tier 4 (non-preferred brand) exceeds $75; Tier 5 (specialty) involves 25-33% coinsurance, potentially hundreds per month for biologics or cancer treatments.

When reviewing a formulary, check not just whether your drug is listed, but which tier it occupies. A medication that was on Tier 2 in 2025 but moves to Tier 4 in 2026 can increase your annual out-of-pocket costs by $500 or more, depending on how frequently you refill it. The Medicare Part D formulary lookup tool allows you to search by drug name and see its tier status across all plans in your area.

Prior Authorization and Step Therapy Requirements

Many plans require prior authorization before covering certain drugs, even if listed on the formulary. This process typically takes 24-72 hours. Some plans also impose step therapy, requiring you to try a lower-cost medication first before the plan covers a more expensive alternative, even if your doctor deems it medically necessary.

Step therapy is common for depression, high cholesterol, and diabetes drugs. If you are on a medication that works well, verify whether step therapy applies in 2026. If it does, ask your doctor to submit a prior authorization request based on medical necessity to bypass the requirement.

The Coverage Gap and Catastrophic Coverage

The coverage gap (donut hole) still exists in Part D for 2026. Once combined spending reaches $5,850, you pay a higher percentage until out-of-pocket spending reaches $7,050. Then catastrophic coverage kicks in, and you pay only 5% coinsurance for the remainder of the year.

For beneficiaries with chronic conditions requiring expensive medications, the coverage gap can be a significant cost driver. The Medicare Part D coverage gap explanation outlines how your costs change once you reach the gap threshold. Some plans offer better coverage in the gap than others, so if you anticipate high drug costs, compare how each plan handles the gap phase, not just the initial coverage phase.

Verifying Pharmacy Network and Preferred Pharmacies

Your formulary is only useful if your preferred pharmacy is in-network. Some plans restrict coverage to mail-order pharmacies for maintenance medications; others offer retail pharmacies. Verify your current pharmacy is in-network or confirm you can switch. Mail-order typically offers 90-day supplies at lower copayment than 30-day retail fills.

Learn More →

Watch Out Failing to verify your medications against the new formulary is the most common reason beneficiaries face surprise pharmacy bills in January. A drug that was covered in 2025 may not be covered in 2026, or it may have moved to a higher tier. Always cross-reference your current prescriptions against the 2026 formulary before you enroll.

Step 4: Calculate Your Out-of-Pocket Costs for 2026

Your out-of-pocket maximum is the financial ceiling protecting you from catastrophic expenses. Medicare Advantage plans have an annual limit on Part A and B cost-sharing; Original Medicare has no such cap. Understanding this distinction is central to any plan review.

To calculate realistic costs, consider your known healthcare usage from the past year. Add up your doctor visits, specialist appointments, lab work, and prescriptions, then apply each plan's cost-sharing structure to that usage pattern. Many beneficiaries find that a plan with a slightly higher monthly premium offers substantially lower copayments for the services they actually use, making it the more economical choice overall. When comparing plans, also factor in how the Medicare out-of-pocket cost protections apply to your specific situation.

Cost Factor Original Medicare Medicare Advantage
Out-of-Pocket Maximum No annual cap Set annual limit
Part D Coverage Separate standalone plan Often included
Provider Network Any accepting doctor Usually restricted
Monthly Premium Part B only Varies by plan

Making Your Final Decision and Enrollment

Once you have compared plans, act before the enrollment deadline. The Medicare Open Enrollment Period runs October 15-December 7, with changes taking effect January 1. Missing this window locks you into current coverage for another year, so start your review in September.

Hidden Costs of Switching Plans

Switching plans carries hidden costs. A new Medicare Advantage plan may impose a new deductible even if you met the previous one. Your new network may require changing doctors or pharmacies, and ongoing treatment may need new prior authorizations. Some specialists may not be in-network, forcing provider switches or out-of-network costs.

If switching to a Medicare Advantage plan, verify your current doctors participate in the new network by calling their offices directly; online directories are outdated. Confirm your prescriptions are covered under the new formulary and your pharmacy is in-network.

For beneficiaries with chronic conditions, switching plans can disrupt continuity of care. Verify that ongoing therapies, imaging, or procedures are pre-authorized under your new plan before January 1, and ask your current doctor to submit necessary paperwork in advance.

Caregiver Checklist for Medicare Plan Review

If you are helping a family member navigate their 2026 Medicare plan options, use this checklist to ensure nothing is overlooked:

Before Open Enrollment Begins (September-October):

  • Obtain a copy of the beneficiary's current plan's Summary of Benefits and Coverage.
  • Request the Annual Notice of Change from the current plan (arrives in September).
  • Collect a list of all current prescriptions, including dosages and refill frequency.
  • Gather a list of current doctors and specialists, including their names and specialties.
  • Note any planned medical procedures, surgeries, or treatments for 2026.
  • Confirm whether the beneficiary qualifies for Extra Help (low-income subsidy) or a Medicare Savings Program.
  • Review the beneficiary's out-of-pocket costs from the past year to establish a baseline.

During Open Enrollment (October 15-December 7):

  • Log into Medicare.gov Plan Finder and enter the beneficiary's ZIP code, medications, and preferred pharmacies.
  • Compare at least three plans side by side, noting premiums, deductibles, and estimated annual costs.
  • Verify that each plan's top-choice doctors are in-network by calling their offices directly.
  • Check the 2026 formulary for each plan and confirm all current medications are covered.
  • Note the tier and copayment for each medication under each plan.
  • Identify whether any medications require prior authorization or step therapy under the new plan.
  • Confirm that the beneficiary's preferred pharmacy is in-network for each plan being considered.
  • Review the plan's coverage of any anticipated medical services (e.g., physical therapy, home health, durable medical equipment).
  • Compare out-of-pocket maximums and coverage gap provisions if the beneficiary has high drug costs.
  • Make a final plan choice and enroll before December 7.

After Enrollment (December 8-January 1):

  • Confirm receipt of the new plan's member ID card and welcome packet.
  • Update the beneficiary's doctors' offices with the new insurance information.
  • Notify the current pharmacy of the plan change and confirm the new plan's formulary and copayments.
  • Request any necessary prior authorizations from the new plan for ongoing treatments or medications.
  • Verify that the new plan's coverage begins on January 1 with no gaps.
  • Set a reminder to review the beneficiary's plan again in September 2027.

Enrollment Methods and Deadlines

Enroll during the Medicare Open Enrollment Period online at Medicare.gov, by phone at 1-800-MEDICARE, or in person at a local Social Security office. Online enrollment is fastest; phone enrollment is preferable if you need help or have complex coverage needs.

If you qualify for Extra Help or a Medicare Savings Program, you may change plans more frequently than standard periods. Contact your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) to confirm eligibility and learn about special enrollment periods.

Pro Tip If you are helping a parent or spouse with Medicare, consider scheduling a call with a licensed Medicare counselor at your local SHIP office. These services are free and can provide personalized guidance for complex plan decisions, especially if the beneficiary has multiple chronic conditions or high drug costs.

Conclusion

Reviewing your Medicare coverage each year controls healthcare costs and ensures your plan fits your needs. Gather documents, use official comparison tools, verify drug coverage, and calculate out-of-pocket exposure. The Senior Benefits Center simplifies this process with licensed agents providing personalized guidance for complex decisions. Get started and make your 2026 review straightforward and stress-free.

Frequently Asked Questions

When does the Medicare Open Enrollment Period for 2026 begin?

The Medicare Open Enrollment Period for 2026 runs from October 15, 2025, through December 7, 2025. During this window, you can review your current Medicare coverage, compare available plans in your area, and make changes to your health or prescription drug plan without penalty. Changes you make during this period become effective January 1, 2026. Missing this deadline means you're locked into your current plan for the entire year unless you experience a qualifying life event.

Do I need to review my Medicare plan every year?

Yes, annual review is essential. Insurance companies change premiums, deductibles, copayments, and provider networks each year. Your prescription drug formulary may shift, affecting your medication costs. Your health needs may change, making a different plan type more suitable. Even if your current plan served you well in 2025, it may no longer be the best fit for 2026. A yearly review ensures you're not overpaying or losing access to your doctors and medications.

What should I look for when comparing Medicare plans?

Focus on five key areas: premium costs, deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance amounts; your provider network and whether your current doctors participate; prescription drug coverage and any formulary changes affecting your medications; out-of-pocket cost caps, which protect you from catastrophic expenses; and plan quality ratings, which reflect how well the plan serves its members. Use the Medicare plan comparison tool on Medicare.gov to see side-by-side details for plans available in your zip code.

How do star ratings affect my choice of Medicare plan?

Medicare star ratings measure plan quality on a scale of 1 to 5 stars based on member satisfaction, health outcomes, and customer service performance. Higher-rated plans generally deliver better care coordination and member support. When reviewing your options, prioritize plans with 4 or 5 stars, especially if you have chronic conditions requiring coordinated care. Star ratings are updated annually and are one of the most reliable indicators of real-world plan performance beyond just cost.